Economy

Stolen Wages

From the late 1800s until the 1970s Aboriginal workers were for all intents and purposes enslaved. They were denied access to their wages which in many cases were simply stolen by corrupt officials and employers. It locked them into a cycle of poverty.

Governments and churches have made it difficult to access records and there is a general reluctance to pay the monies withheld.

Selected statistic data

$10
Wage some stolen wages claimants received a month. Same wage for white persons: $60 [22].
10
Number of stolen wages claimants who died in 2009 and again in 2010 [22].
70%
Maximum percentage of wages the Australian government could legally take from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people [22].
8
Months it takes government departments to answer individual requests for information due to lack of staff [28].

In Queensland, Jubilee Jackson worked as a stockman near Mt Garnet for 60 years from the age of ten. His pay was a small amount of pocket money at rodeo time. The rest was held in a trust account. When he died in 1967 there was only $99 in his government controlled account.Hard Labour, Stolen Wages [3]

Why were wages “stolen”?

Many Aboriginal people who worked for white people did not receive their wages directly. Their bosses only gave them ‘pocket money’ while from 1897 to the late 1970s their wages were ‘administered’ for them by government or police authorities [1]. In Western Australia wages were under “total government control” until 1968 [26].

The contribution Aboriginal people made to Australia’s economy with their largely unfairly paid or unpaid work is a history seldom told.

“Aboriginal people are often denigrated as being a drain on the nation’s economy, but if you look at the facts it’s actually the other way around, with Aboriginal labour being used to build the economy without due payment or even recognition,” says Dennis Eggington, Chief Executive of the Aboriginal Legal Service of Western Australia [26]. “It’s a terrible injustice that has been perpetrated over many decades, with the truth hidden from the official version of Australian history.”

There is no doubt in my mind that this country's strong economy was born on the backs of Aboriginal labour.—Rachael Sievert, WA Green Senator [24]

When I was in school, I was told that Australia developed on the sheep's back. I now know that it developed on the backs of thousand of Aboriginal men, women and children.—Gary Highland, National Director, Australians for Native Title and Reconciliation (ANTaR) [25]

Between 1916 and 1960 money of Aboriginal workers from Victoria was withheld as punishment, with wages and contracts being controlled by the Aboriginal Protection Board [21]. Not every worker was affected though.

Today we talk about ‘stolen wages’ because in many cases Aboriginal people did not receive parts or all of these wages. Historians estimate that the state of Queensland alone owes around $500 million to Aboriginal people [1]. Some individuals are owed close to half a million dollars in today’s terms [31].

According to the dictionary, if someone “works under duress and without payment” they are considered slaves. The stolen wages are always about the slavery Australia denies until today.

Governments withheld, among other monies, wages, child endowments and pensions. Documents exist showing that governments knew exactly what they were doing, and that they were breaking the law [24,25].

Lawyers know that stolen wages claimants’ demands rest on legal right and not on the uncertain and contestable ground of moral right [31], however governments show excellence in delaying and rejecting claims. Time works against Aboriginal people as they grow older and die without receiving compensation.

Fact Until 1972, laws in WA allowed employers to hold 75% of the wages of Aboriginal people in a complex network of trust accounts that were administered by government departments [32].

Australia’s Aboriginal slaves

“A woman reported to me that as a young woman she slept in a shed. Her day began before dawn when she commenced to prepare the employer’s family’s breakfast, then attended to the invalid grand mother, had breakfast on enamel utensils specially set apart for her, cleaned up the kitchen, did some house work then did ploughing or fencing with the farmer, returned at dusk to make the meals, cleaned up and put the grand mother and then herself to bed. This woman had no other company, was not taken on or given outings and had no means to travel, had no holidays, was paid no money and chose no item of clothing for herself until after she ran away when she was about 30 years old.” [18]

“At the age of 10, transferred to the Salvation Army Home for Boys at Indoroopilly, that was a lesson I will never forget, I scrubbed floors, helped in the kitchen, worked from daylight till dawn, washing clothes in the laundry, which was slave labour.” [19]

“I used to start work on Tuesdays from 6 o’clock and work through to 11 o’clock at night because I’d be looking after 6 children - the youngest would have been eight months. I was not even 14 at the time… it was like slave labour.” [29]

Research by Dr Rosalind Kidd shows that the government-inflicted treatment of Aboriginal people resulted in “starvation, under-payment or no payment of wages, sexual abuse of workers, conditions tantamount to slavery, and abduction.” [23]

Contracts issues by governments made leaving a punishable offence. If people did leave, in most states police hunted them and returned them in chains [25].

Children and elderly had to work for rations so scarce that malnutrition was ‘rampant’ [25].

It was claimed at the time that cash wages perverted the work ethic. There is a word for this--slavery.—Dr Rosalind Kidd, author [25]

Stolen wages, stolen future

Many Aboriginal people whose wages were stolen were also stolen children, denying them cultural and economic futures.

“As a result of my growing up ‘under the [Aboriginals Preservation and Protection] Act’, I received a limited education. As such, I had limited job opportunities. When my husband died, it was financially difficult to raise my three small children on my limited income and widows’ pension. It would have eased the financial burden if I was able to access the balance of my savings account and the interest accumulated over the years.” [4]

We could have had our own homes from the wage we are owed, and had the ability to set things up for our children. It breaks your heart to see our children still struggling.—Marjorie Woodrow, Aboriginal stolen wages claimant [2]

Majorie Woodrow, stolen wages claimant.
Marjorie Woodrow, one of the many claimants for stolen wages.

It makes sense for Aboriginal people to argue that they would not be stereotyped as welfare-dependent if they had had full access to the economic base stolen from them—their wages.

The majority of Australians have yet to acknowledge the “evident link between settlement life, stolen wages and the lack of education and employment in today’s society” [16]. How are Aboriginal people to become successful workers and businessmen when they are locked into a cycle of poverty?

Aboriginal people have still not received the recognition they deserve for their contribution to Australia’s economic prosperity. Without Aboriginal people Australia would not be where it is today, specifically in industries like farming or pearling.

Besides wages, government also withheld other monies such as child endowment, maternity allowance, trust funds, workers’ compensation, pensions and deceased estates.

"It was like working on a prison farm"

Snippet from Melrose Donley's story. Melrose Donley remembers: "The day started at 3.30am to round up cows in the dark, barefooted, chilblains on my feet, falling over logs and when a cow from lying on the ground, upon rising, would do her dropping, it being warm I would rub it up my legs and the warmth from it would ease the pain." [19].

Melrose’s story (pdf, 127kB)

Colin Graham

Snippet from Colin Graham's story. Colin Graham was born in 1947. He started work at the age of nine. Read about his difficult life, hard work, lack of education, racism and how South Africa’s Apartheid system modelled Queensland’s Aboriginal Protection Act [17].

Colin’s story (pdf, 169kB)

The cycle of poverty of Aboriginal people due to their wages being stolen.
The cycle of poverty many Aboriginal people fall into because their wages were stolen [16].

Finding records on stolen wages

Every state had an Aboriginal Protection Board where bureaucrats and policemen meticulously recorded what was going on in their reserves and missions. Today these documents are kept with the State Records authorities. When you lodge a stolen wages claim, staff of the State Records authorities search their archives for documents supporting it.

Stolen wages claimants Valerie Wenberg and Nancy Hill in a NSW record building.
Stolen wages claimants Valerie Linow and Nancy Wood with ABC reporter Peter George in a NSW State Records building researching documents about the wages owed to them. Despite the smiles the process was difficult and tearful. Photo: ABC

Records might be incomplete because of poor bookkeeping or because they were deliberately destroyed to cover fraudulent use of Aboriginal money [9], especially when the Aboriginal Welfare Board was disbanded in the late 1960s [8, 15].

“We know that many of these files were destroyed or burned or have gone missing,” explains Dennis Eggington, CEO of the Aboriginal Legal Service of Western Australia [28]. “Getting the right material and the right information back out of the system is by far going to be the trickiest part.”

“I remember a case when I was a senior welfare officer at Moree in the 1970s,” says Les Ridgeway, an Aboriginal elder from NSW [30]. “An instruction came down from the head office of the child welfare department instructing all the district offices around NSW to go out on the mission stations or reserves, collect those old files out of the former managers’ offices, take them to the town dump and burn them.” Today these files would be of immense value to Aboriginal people.

Furthermore most records are not digitised. All of this makes it extremely difficult for claimants of stolen wages to prove their case and is the main reason for low levels of successful applicants.

A documentary by Australian Broadcasting Corporation’s television channel (ABC) [8] found that Aboriginal people were paid or issued cheques, but these cheques simply never got to the people for whom they were intended. Many were forgotten in the safes of a local police station because the police couldn’t be bothered to go out to find these people. Some of the cheques were also pocketed.

When hunting for documents many stolen wages claimants are left to their own devices as departments and governments refuse access to documents.

  • The Queensland government is said to have “refused to supply documents within its possession which would assist in identifying claims” and the Commonwealth Bank, which held “many of the monies” has probably never been asked to produce its records [15].
  • The Department of Indigenous Affairs “censored” files when it removed name references prior to reluctantly handing the documents to Aboriginal people [26].
  • The West Australian Government has not opened up its archive for descendants of stolen wages victims [27].

Stolen wages claimants who worked under the control of church institutions have similar problems because the churches have been reluctant to make their records available [10]. Organisations need to use Freedom of Information processes to retrieve relevant documents.

Some people want the process reversed, that is the government should prove that it does not owe money to the claimant.

I didn't even know anything about money. I didn't know how to spend money. [...] I was there to obey.—Valerie Linow, trained to be a domestic servant [8]

Form for the exemption of the Aborigines Protection Act.
Supportive document to make a claim for stolen wages. Note also the questions whether the applicant is ‘intelligent enough’ to ‘understand the value of money’. [14]

Stolen Wages support groups

Stolen Wages Working Groups

Stolen Wages Working Groups (SWWGs) exist in major cities and meet about once a month. They consist of elders, claimants, family and other Aboriginal community representatives of the former workers affected by stolen wages, trade union representatives, ANTaR and other concerned community groups and individuals.

The Stolen Wages Working Groups’ campaign has the following goals:

  • Current compensation offers should be considered a down payment.
  • The offer should be extended to families of deceased workers.
  • Closure for the stolen wages issue must be renegotiated directly with Aboriginal communities.
  • Establish the rights of claimants of stolen wages to determine what should happen with the leftover funds.

It has taken SWWGs nearly six years to find a minister who was prepared to sit down and talk with them [11].

Wampan Wages

The Wampan Wages (‘Pay back wages’) Victorian Stolen Wages Working Group is an informal working group made up of Indigenous and non-Indigenous people who have an interest in stolen wages and Indigenous justice.

The group facilitates research into stolen wages and other entitlements owed to Victorian Aboriginal people. It also lobbies for funding of a research project into the incidents of stolen wages in the state [20].

Resources

Hard Labour, Stolen Wages; report by ANTaR. Read Rosalind Kidd’s Hard Labour, Stolen Wages report which gives a state by state account of the history of stolen wages.

Stolen Wages senate inquiry Browse the submissions to the senate inquiry into stolen wages which give you an authentic picture about working conditions, types of jobs and how Aboriginal people felt at that time (check the quotes on this page).

Stolen wages in the U.S.

Stolen wages is not an issue unique to Australia. Since the late 19th century the U.S. government has been in charge of a trust fund known as the ‘Individual Indian Monies Trust’ [12]. It was established when the U.S. Congress parcelled out land owned by a number of American Aboriginal tribes.

Excess lands allotted to people from those tribes were put in trust and managed by the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), an agency of the Department of the Interior. Trust beneficiaries derive income from royalties on their land, which the BIA leases out for activities such as logging, oil and gas exploration, and grazing.

But for more than 100 years these trust fund monies have been grossly mismanaged. To this day the U.S. Treasury Department issues cheques on an account, worth billions of dollars, which cannot be balanced or reconciled.

The U.S. Department of the Interior has been found guilty of breaching trust obligations to at least 300,000 Indigenous Americans.

Footnotes

View article sources (28)

[1] Koori Mail 406, 'Stolen Wages lifeline', p.1
[2] in: 'Hard Labour, Stolen Wages', Rosalind Kidd, ANTaR report August 2007, p.6
[3] 'Hard Labour, Stolen Wages', loc. cit., p.8
[4] Stolen Wages committee submissions, aph.gov.au/Senate/Committee/legcon_ctte/stolen_wages/submissions/sublist.htm, submission #82
[8] 'Rewind' program on ABC, 17 October 2004
[9] Stolen Wages committee submissions, loc. cit., submission #40
[10] 'Give us back our money', Sydney Morning Herald, 15 December 2007
[11] Koori Mail 406, loc. cit., p.6
[12] 'Blackfeet Reservation Development Fund', http://www.lannan.org/lf/ic/special-projects/blackfeet-reservation-development-fund/
[14] Stolen Wages committee submissions, loc. cit., submission #12
[15] Stolen Wages committee submissions, loc. cit., submission #21
[16] 'Queensland Reparations Offer for Wages and Savings: Community Effects, Reactions and Responses', Kristie Smith, 2006
[17] Stolen Wages committee submissions, loc. cit., submission #61
[18] Stolen Wages committee submissions, loc. cit., submission #77
[19] Stolen Wages committee submissions, loc. cit., submission #115
[20] 'Stolen Wages in Victoria' http://www.antarvictoria.org.au/stolenwages.html
[21] 'Report refects wage claims', Koori Mail 467 p.12
[22] 'We want our money', Koori Mail 482 p.43
[23] 'New anger at inaction over wages', Koori Mail 484 p.26
[24] 'WA reparation call for stolen wages victims', Koori Mail 411 p.10
[25] ''Government theft' - Report chronicles extent of stolen wages 'fraud'', Koori Mail 409 p.15
[26] 'Class action move over stolen wages', Koori Mail 401 p.10
[27] 'Wages offer anger', Koori Mail 523 p.12
[28] 'Concerns held over access to WA records', Koori Mail 426 p.16
[29] 'Mary wages campaign for fairness', Koori Mail 394 p.17
[30] 'Fight for justice', Koori Mail 392 p.14
[31] ''Scandalous injustice'', Koori Mail 391 p.7
[32] 'Stolen Wages', Robin Chapple, http://www.robinchapple.com/stolen-wages retri,eved 24/4/2014

Cite this article

An appropriate citation for this document is:

www.CreativeSpirits.info,
Aboriginal culture - Economy - Stolen Wages, retrieved 20 September 2014